Where's the best place to get a slice in Sayville?
Question of the Day: Pizza
We ask, you answer.
Comments + Leave a Comment
Steve September 16, 2011 at 05:09 pm
To me the best place for a slice is in the SunVet Mall at Aegean Pizza. I know thats not Sayville but their pizza has been consistently amazing for 35 + years.
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Susan Brass September 16, 2011 at 05:39 pm
Sal's Pizza is definitely the best. We moved to Sayville last summer and tried them all. Great sauce with a crispy crust... just perfect. The staff is great too, always walk out with a smile!
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Gerimay September 16, 2011 at 08:56 pm
We like RJ's Pizza on Lakeland Ave in Sayville. The pizza and the garlic knots are so delicious. Service is quick, delivery arrives hot and just what you order. We've tried a few other pizza places, but this one is our favorite.
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Marc Frontino September 17, 2011 at 05:13 am
Marc Anthony's is the place to go. The staff is friendly and everything we have ever had there is delicious.
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Rick September 17, 2011 at 12:10 pm
Tied for first is Sal's and Sayville. Both awesome!!
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Vinny Fuori September 18, 2011 at 07:55 pm
Sal's all the way.
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Love this town September 22, 2011 at 04:56 pm
Went to Sayville Pizza for a while when we first moved here. Problem is that the price is ALWAYS different. I got tired of getting ripped off. Asked why the price difference and they were nasty and told me to go someplace else. Went to Marc Anthony's 2 weeks ago and loved it.
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Mark Ebstien September 22, 2011 at 09:51 pm
Funny had the same problem with Sayville Pizza. Now you will find me at Sal's every friday. Great heros! 2 Pies and a meatball parm hearo ! ! !
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Dee September 28, 2011 at 06:26 pm
Marc Anthony is Awesome ! Sayville makes you want to puke . Sal's used to be good a few years ago . Thet changed the formula especially on the sicilian . Went there not one , not two , but three times in a row and they screwed up my order while AT THE COUNTER ! As soon as Marc Anthony's opened that was it . Great Brooklyn pies , Like a Grandma's but with mozzarella on the bottom and then the sauce and the antipasta is great . There is no comparison to any of the pizza places .
Recommend
Flag as Inappropriate
Boards
All Boards »
Judy Mottl (Editor) June 5, 2013 at 01:11 pm
I think the town beaches are opening officially later this month, around June 29 I believe and some…Read More opened just for Memorial Day weekend.
Bill Mueller June 7, 2013 at 10:58 am
probably because most of the lifeguards are still in high school and have classes during the week…Read More until the end of June